Broncos Get Good News About ‘Overpaid’ $55 Million Pro Bowler

   

The Denver Broncos have been the rage of the offseason for their aggressive approach to fix several areas of need. Several Broncos veterans remain in line for new deals after strong 2024 campaigns, including wide receiver Courtland Sutton.

Time to trade for Courtland Sutton in fantasy football?

A Pro Bowler in 2019, Sutton turns 30 in October and is entering the final year of a two-year, $27.5 million contract, a deal he and the Broncos re-worked from a four-year, $60 million pact.

9News’ Mike Klis reported on an expected new deal.

“Sources tell 9NEWS there have been enough good-faith bargaining discussions made between the two sides that unlike last year, Sutton is planning to attend the Broncos’ offseason training program when players are scheduled to report April 21,” Klis wrote on March 30.

“Sutton has one year and $14 million left on his contract, and with 25 receivers scheduled to make more in 2025, it’s been communicated to the Broncos that a reworked contract is expected.”

This comes after Bleacher Report’s Brad Gagnon called Sutton the “most overpaid” Bronco.

“There are no egregious contracts on the payroll for this well-built team, but Sutton’s isn’t great,” Gagnon wrote on March 26. “The 29-year-old has not gone over 1,100 yards since he was a sophomore in 2019, but he’s slated to count $20.2 million against the cap in a walk year in 2025.”

Sutton caught 81 passes for 1,084 yards and 8 touchdowns for the Broncos in 2024. Only six other receivers posted lines that were as good or better than Sutton’s last season, per Stathead.

Five of them earned Pro Bowl honors, three were All-Pros.

Sutton set a new career-high in receptions while the yardage was his second-best output. A second-round pick by the Broncos (No. 40 overall) in 2018, he has earned $55.2 million in his career. Klis expects Sutton to get a raise from his current $20 million annual salary.

Courtland Sutton on Fair-Market Deal

Sutton held out from part of the voluntary portion of the 2024 offseason before he and the Broncos re-worked his deal to end the stalemate. That set the stage for the current climate, but Altitude Sports’ Brett Kane believes the Broncos are still paying a commensurate value for Sutton.

Kane strongly did not agree with Gagnon’s assessment of Sutton.

“I was just looking at some headlines yesterday on Bleacher Report,” Kane said on “Moser, Lombardi, & Kane” on March 28. “Before I hit the link, I just sat there to myself for a good three, four, five minutes. I said, ‘Who the hell would the Broncos’ be? Who are they going to say before I open up this article? Who would they say?’ And after about five minutes of thinking about it, you know what my answer is? Couldn’t think of one. I don’t think that there’s a single person I would say is overpaid.”

“Maybe they were just trying to come up with a name. I’ll say this about Courtland Sutton: I think he’s a rarity in sports, where I think $20.2 [million] is the exact right price for Courtland Sutton.”

“I think by his production, $20 million bucks sounds like it’s on the money actually,” Kane said.

Sutton has the 10th-highest cap hit among receivers in 2025 as of March 30. Moreover, his original deal ranked 22nd in total value. A new deal could free up $9.8 million in additional cap space for the Broncos, per Over The Cap.

Broncos Addressed Courtland Sutton at Scouting Combine

The discussion could end up moot given the comments from Broncos general manager George Paton and head coach Sean Payton at the 2025 scouting combine.

“Those discussions will take place between George and Courtland’s representatives,” Payton told reporters in February. “We felt like he had a real good season. He’s important to what we’re doing. So all of that will happen in time.”

“Courtland’s one of our guys. Team captain,” Paton told reporters on February 25. “We want him here. We’ll have those discussions at the right time. We’ll meet with his agent here like we always do with all the agents.”

That is exactly what happened, per Klis.

“The Broncos assured Sutton and his agent Jacob Presser during a meeting last month at the NFL Combine in Indianapolis they would negotiate with them in good faith on a fair contract extension. It was understood the timing of those talks was expected to come some time after the draft that will be held April 24-26, Klis wrote.

“In return, Sutton, who has been elected a team captain by his teammates each of the previous four seasons, offered his show of good faith by saying he would continue to lead from within the building when the Broncos return for offseason workouts.”