George Paton’s legacy on the line as Denver Broncos face critical decision on GM extension

Denver Broncos Face Pivotal Decision on GM George Paton’s Future:

The Denver Broncos find themselves at a critical juncture as they navigate a series of contract extensions this season. With key players on both sides of the ball entering free agency, including defensive linemen Zach Allen, John Franklin-Myers, and Malcolm Roach, as well as All-Pro linebacker Nik Bonitto and top receiver Courtland Sutton, the Broncos have a busy offseason ahead. While the financial resources are available to secure extensions for these players, the pressing question remains: will the Broncos actually follow through?

Before addressing the roster, the Broncos must first focus on their front office. General manager George Paton is entering the final year of his contract, and his future hangs in the balance. Despite some missteps during his tenure, he has forged a promising partnership with head coach Sean Payton, leading the team through a rapid rebuild. However, it’s important to note that Paton’s initial decisions contributed significantly to the team’s current predicament, particularly the ill-fated trade for quarterback Russell Wilson and the hiring of head coach Nathaniel Hackett in 2022. These moves resulted in wasted financial and draft resources, leaving the Wilson contract as a lingering burden for another season.

Fortunately for the Broncos, co-owner and CEO Greg Penner intervened during the Wilson negotiations, preventing a potentially disastrous seven-year, fully guaranteed deal worth $350 million. While Paton’s earlier blunders cannot be overlooked, he has demonstrated a keen eye for talent in scouting and drafting players, which has been crucial in the team’s turnaround.

Drafting for Success

Paton’s first draft with the Broncos showcased his ability to prioritize long-term value over immediate needs. Instead of selecting a quarterback like Justin Fields or Mac Jones, he opted for cornerback Patrick Surtain II, a decision that has proven transformative. Surtain emerged as a Defensive Player of the Year, significantly impacting the team’s defensive strategy. The 2021 draft also yielded standout players like Quinn Meinerz, a top guard, and pass rusher Jonathon Cooper, solidifying Paton’s reputation for drafting talent.

As the Broncos look ahead to the 2023 draft, the early returns have been mixed. While Marvin Mims Jr. has made a name for himself as an All-Pro returner, the team has yet to fully utilize his offensive potential. Riley Moss has shown promise as a starting cornerback, though injuries have hindered his contributions. The remaining picks, including linebacker Drew Sanders, safety JL Skinner, and center Alex Forsyth, are still finding their footing in the NFL, with Sanders and Skinner battling for roster spots.

Despite the uncertainty surrounding the 2023 draft class, the early signs from the 2024 group are encouraging. Much of this success can be attributed to Payton’s influence and coaching staff, but Paton’s scouting acumen remains a vital asset to the organization.

Navigating Free Agency and Front Office Structure

Paton has also made significant strides in free agency, reshaping the Broncos’ roster through smart acquisitions. His efforts to enhance the front office have not gone unnoticed, as evidenced by the interest from other NFL teams during the recent hiring cycle. Assistant GM Darren Mougey’s departure to the New York Jets underscores the respect Paton has garnered within league circles.

While Paton deserves scrutiny for his past decisions, he merits recognition for the progress the Broncos have made under his leadership. His initial challenges, particularly the Wilson and Hackett misadventures, have been countered by a more stable franchise direction. The continuity established with Payton has been a crucial element in the team’s recovery, and both executives have emphasized its importance.

Paton expressed confidence in the stability this continuity brings, stating, “I feel so much more settled, and I feel like this is the most prepared I’ll be for a draft in large part because of the continuity we’ve had.” Payton echoed this sentiment, highlighting the significance of having the right ownership, coaching staff, and front office in place to foster success.

As the Broncos prepare to negotiate extensions for their deserving players, the most pressing matter remains the future of George Paton. Before finalizing any player contracts, the team must prioritize securing a new deal for their general manager, ensuring that the momentum built during this pivotal period continues unabated.