Joel steps in to defend Ellie, but Ellie gets mad at him for doing so.
Ellie has her first kiss with Dina on the dancefloor, then the euphoria of that romantic moment is interrupted by a homophobic remark from Seth. Joel steps in to defend Ellie, but Ellie gets mad at him for doing so. When the TV show adapts this sequence, it’s important to show the electric chemistry between Ellie and Dina, as well as the bitterness and hostility that Ellie holds toward Joel. It’ll be tough to pull off both effectively within the same scene.
5Joel's Death
HBO's Crucial Scene
![Ellie is forced to watch Joel's death in The Last of Us Part II]()
Arguably the most important scene in The Last of Us Part II — and the trickiest one for the TV show to get right — is Joel’s death. This is the inciting incident of the whole story, and it needs to achieve a very specific emotional response from the audience. It needs to surprise viewers with the rug-pull that damsel-in-distress Abby is actually a vengeful killing machine who’s been hunting Joel for years. It needs to shock them with the graphic brutality of the murder. Bella Ramsey’s cries of horror need to feel just as heartbreakingly authentic as Ashley Johnson’s.
In order for the ensuing revenge narrative to land, this sequence needs to make the audience hate Abby just as much as Ellie does, and make them want vengeance just as much as Ellie does. The audience will go along with Ellie’s dark journey, just as they did in the game, if they want Abby dead just as much as she does. This all paves the way for the midpoint twist, that Abby is actually sympathetic, to land as powerfully as it does.
4Ellie Reveals Her Immunity & Dina Reveals Her Pregnancy
Immunity & Pregnancy: HBO's Key
It’s difficult to pull off any scene that contains a bombshell revelation about one of the main characters, but it’s nearly impossible to pull off a scene that contains two. Toward the end of Ellie’s first day in Seattle, her gas mask breaks and, much to Dina’s shock and confusion, Ellie breathes in spores without getting infected. As they seek refuge in an abandoned theater, Ellie reveals that she’s immune to Cordyceps. She had previously tried to tell Dina about her immunity, but Dina didn’t believe her until she saw it with her own eyes.
Off the back of Ellie’s immunity confession, Dina reveals that she’s pregnant.
Dina’s pregnancy is a huge shock to an audience that’s been watching her narrowly avoid death all day. It drastically complicates Ellie’s quest for revenge, because now there are sky-high stakes and a clear reason to turn back and abandon the mission. Ellie’s immunity isn’t a surprise to the audience, but it is a surprise to Dina. There are a lot of emotions going around in this scene, so it’s a tricky tightrope to walk.
3Ellie Tortures Nora
Nora Scene: HBO's Raw Emotion
![A red-hued Ellie (Bella Ramsey) points a gun in The Last of Us Season 2]()
The most recent trailer for The Last of Us season 2 teased a faithful translation of one of the grimmest scenes in the game: when Ellie tortures Nora for Abby’s location. The shot of Ramsey bathed in ominous red light in a hospital hallway is taken directly from the game. This is when Ellie’s relentless road to revenge starts to chip away at her humanity. She’s so desperate to find Abby and avenge Joel that she’s willing to throw all morality out the window and beat a helpless woman to death to coerce her into betraying her friend.
The game had the benefit of being able to force the player to actually press the button to beat Nora with the pipe, making them an active participant in Ellie’s transition to the dark side. The TV show won’t be able to actively involve the audience in the torture scene, so it might have to make it even more violent to have the same effect. Based on the violence in season 1 (and HBO’s other shows), this surely won’t be a problem.
2Ellie Learns The Truth
TLOU2: Truth, HBO's Impact
![Joel tells Ellie the truth in The Last of Us Part II]()
Ellie’s three days in Seattle are peppered with flashbacks that provide context about the past couple of years of her relationship with Joel. These flashbacks range from heartwarming, like their trip to a dinosaur and aerospace museum, to horrifying, like their gruesome encounter with a bloater in a dilapidated hotel. But the toughest one for the TV show to get right will be when Ellie goes back to St. Mary’s Hospital in Salt Lake City and finally learns the truth about what happened after they reached the Fireflies.
After finding a recording by a Firefly medic confirming that the story Joel told her was a total fabrication, Ellie forces him to tell her what really happened. Joel confesses that they could’ve turned her immunity into a cure, but the operation would’ve killed her, so he stopped them. Pedro Pascal needs to deliver Joel’s grizzled, reluctant confession as effectively as Troy Baker, and Ramsey needs to capture Ellie’s devastation and anger as effectively as Johnson.
1Joel & Ellie's Heart-To-Heart On The Porch
Porch Moment: HBO's Connection
![Joel (Pedro Pascal) playing the guitar in The Last of Us Season 2 Teaser]()
In the game, the conversation between Joel and Ellie on Joel’s porch doesn’t appear until the very end, when Ellie returns to an empty house with two missing fingers, and it recolors everything that came before it. But since Joel is seen playing his guitar on the porch and Ellie is seen approaching the house in the season 2 trailer, it seems as though the TV show will be moving this scene up to the beginning. This scene lays out the conflict between Joel and Ellie and the possible reconciliation that would ultimately never come to pass.
Ellie tells Joel that she’s not sure if she can forgive him for making the biggest decision of her life for her, but she would like to try. This bittersweet heart-to-heart shows that they were about to get their relationship back on track, but that rekindling was cut short when Abby picked up a golf club. This is the scene that ties the whole story together, and The Last of Us season 2 needs to get it right.