Spencer Rattler’s second chance: Will he rise above Tyler Shough in Saints’ puzzling QB battle?

Recent analysis from a notable NFL writer offers a glimpse into the potential outcome of this competition. Moe Moton of Bleacher Report predicts that Rattler will ultimately outshine Shough and secure the QB1 role during training camp. Moton points out that despite Shough’s six years of collegiate experience, he may still require time to adapt to the speed and complexity of the professional game. In contrast, Rattler’s experience as the primary backup last season positions him favorably to retain his spot ahead of Haener and potentially surpass Shough.

While Rattler’s journey has been marred by inconsistency and an underwhelming performance as a starter last season, there remains a belief in his potential to thrive at the professional level. Moton acknowledges Rattler’s physical gifts, yet it’s essential to recognize that his collegiate career was not without its flaws. Despite possessing a powerful arm, he has faced challenges in reading defenses and navigating the pocket effectively.

Shough’s Readiness for Competition

On the other hand, Tyler Shough, at 25, enters the league with the expectation that he should be ready to compete immediately. His age and experience could give him a leg up, but if he struggles to adapt, the Saints may be left with no choice but to evaluate the capabilities of Rattler or Haener. As the Saints aim for a brighter future, securing a competent quarterback could be crucial in their pursuit of high-profile prospects like Arch Manning.

In this unfolding drama, the Saints’ quarterback battle will not only shape the upcoming season but also influence the team’s long-term trajectory. As training camp approaches, all eyes will be on Rattler, Shough, and Haener as they fight for a chance to lead a franchise in search of its identity.