The Tennessee Titans are approaching a crucial stage in their rebuilding process as they prepare to add a fresh group of rookies during next month's draft. While the introduction of young talent is always exciting, it’s clear that a strong foundation of experienced players will be vital to mentor and guide these newcomers. Veterans provide stability, wisdom, and the necessary grit that can help integrate rookies into the team's culture and elevate their performance on the field.
One player who exemplifies these qualities is Roger McCreary, the team’s nickel cornerback, who is entering the final year of his contract. His role on the roster could be essential not only for his contributions as a dependable slot defender but also for the leadership he brings to a transitional team. Bleacher Report writer Alex Ballentine has highlighted McCreary as a candidate for a contract extension this offseason, arguing that he represents the kind of player Tennessee needs to retain to navigate their rebuild effectively.
Ballentine points out that while McCreary had an off-year in coverage in the 2024 season—with a passer rating allowed of 104.9—he showed growth in other areas. His yards allowed per target dropped to a career-low 6.8, showcasing his ability to adapt and refine his skills despite challenges. Moreover, McCreary’s physicality and willingness to engage in the run game are traits that set him apart. With 220 tackles over the last three seasons, he has proven himself as a reliable and hard-nosed defender who can make an impact beyond just pass coverage.
With new general manager Mike Borgonzi at the helm, decisions regarding player retention and roster changes may reflect a fresh vision for the Titans. However, as Ballentine suggests, McCreary’s youth and toughness make him the kind of player worth keeping around, especially during a rebuild that demands both development and consistency. While Borgonzi may hesitate to extend players he didn’t draft, McCreary’s value extends beyond statistics, offering intangibles like leadership, grit, and potential growth.
The Titans face unique challenges as they lack an abundance of draft capital to build entirely from scratch. This reality emphasizes the importance of retaining key members of their existing core while simultaneously infusing the roster with rookie talent. McCreary’s versatility and experience could prove invaluable in bridging the gap between the veterans and the incoming class, especially for a defense that needs to balance physicality with reliability.
After recording 50 tackles in 2024—a dip compared to previous seasons due to injuries and reduced playing time—there’s hope that McCreary can rebound strongly in 2025. With a full season of health and stability, he may return to his earlier form and re-establish himself as a cornerstone of the Titans’ defense. If the team can successfully integrate rookies while retaining players like McCreary, they will be better equipped to navigate the challenges of a rebuild and set the foundation for a bright future.
