While speaking to PEOPLE, Jenn shared that she's completely “hooked” on The Traitors Season 3 and often finds herself imagining how she would navigate the game if she were part of it. The reality star admitted that she would probably be a Faithful if she participated in the game. However, she expressed that it would be fun to deceive people as a Traitor, which would be something completely out of her element. Despite that, Jenn joked that she might not make a very good one.
During The Traitors Season 3 Reunion, which aired alongside the finale on March 6, 2025, Gabby expressed the same sentiment as Jenn. She, too, claimed that after being on The Bachelorette, she knows how to “sniff out the bulls--t fast.” The reality star joked that her experience on the Bachelorette actually helped her realize that she was gay. Gabby, along with her fellow Faithfuls Dolores Catania, Dylan Efron, and Ivar Mountbatten, ultimately won The Traitors Season 3 and took home the $203,300 prize.
Gabby Windey Admits She Fangirled Over Her ‘The Traitors’ Co-Star Chrishell Stause
Gabby came out as gay in August 2023, shortly after she called it quits with Erich Rich, whom she had gotten engaged to during The Bachelorette Season 19 finale. That’s when Gabby also announced that she had been dating comedian Robby Hoffman. Shortly after going public with Robby, Gabby received a DM from Chrishell Stause, who invited her to G-Flip’s album release party. While Gabby and Robby couldn’t attend, they really appreciated the kind gesture.
However, Chrishell wasn’t the only Traitors castmate Gabby developed a close bond with. In another interview with PEOPLE, Gabby shared that the former WWE wrestler, Nikki Garcia, became her “big sister” on the show. The former Bachelorette shared how much she admired Nikki’s long-standing wrestling career. She also reflected on meeting several Real Housewives stars during the season and described them all as “powerhouses.”