Even after being attacked multiple times, Maggie and Hilltop continued to rebuild and by The Walking Dead season 11's ending, it looked like the place was finally at peace along with the show's other prominent locations. Unfortunately, this optimistic conclusion didn't last too long for the people of Hilltop, as by the time Dead City rolled around, things had changed drastically for them. Although they remained united and healthy, Hilltop underwent some massive changes in the few years that passed between The Walking Dead season 11 and Dead City season 1, with Maggie offering an insight into what happened.
What Maggie Reveals About Hilltop's Fate In The Walking Dead: Dead City
Maggie Claimed Hilltop Never Really Recovered From The Whisperer War
During Dead City season 1, Maggie told Negan that Hilltop had to relocate after he "helped burn it down", alluding to the Whisperers' attack on the community. Although Negan killed Alpha and helped kill Beta - the Whisperers' two leading figures - he did briefly join the villainous group so that he could take it down from the inside, which he pulled off flawlessly. However, with Maggie and Negan's long-running Walking Dead feud continuing in Dead City, she clearly didn't get over the fact he didn't at least warn Hilltop about the plan that ultimately destroyed the location beyond repair.
Despite the rebuild seeming successful in season 11, it's clear too much damage was done, as Maggie confirmed that Hilltop relocated, with Dead City revealing it had been renamed to "The Bricks". In addition, the Croat was able to infiltrate Maggie's new version of Hilltop in Dead City and kidnap her son, showing the new location made her people far more vulnerable to Manhattan's factions. Considering Hilltop was still a thriving faction even after battling the Saviors, it can be assumed that the fire damage caused by the Whisperers ruined the terrain and buildings, forcing a fresh start elsewhere.
Where The New Hilltop Is Located Compared To The Original
Hilltop Relocated From Virginia To Somewhere In New York Or New Jersey
Hilltop's residents could have traveled further West, but with the Commonwealth located in Ohio, it would have been a large trip into the unknown to find a new home, and they may have ended up far away from their allied communities. Therefore, setting up camp in New York or New Jersey was the best outcome, but they didn't anticipate so many hostile communities in the area. There are still plenty of unknowns regarding The Bricks' location and how fortified it is following the previous attack, but I'm hopeful Dead City season 2 will explore this in more detail.
Hilltop's Relocation Contradicts The Flashforward From The Walking Dead's Ending
The Walking Dead's Ending Made Hilltop Look Like A Thriving Community
If The Walking Dead continues making such major decisions, it could eventually make "Rest in Peace" feel completely redundant.
As a result, Hilltop's fate is another example of The Walking Dead spinoffs impacting the ending of the original series, as the happy ending now feels like false hope. The franchise continuing through individual projects always meant things were going to change, but season 11's finale no longer feels like a true conclusion for the series since an entire community fell off-camera. Fans haven't seemed too frustrated by the decision to relocate such a prominent settlement, but if The Walking Dead continues making such major decisions, it could eventually make "Rest in Peace" feel completely redundant.
The Fall & Relocation Of Hilltop Is One Of The Walking Dead's Most Interesting Unseen Stories
The Walking Dead Could Still Cover Hilltop's Relocation In Full Through Another Project
With that in mind, it seemed like a no-brainer to depict Hilltop's collapse on-screen and focus on the relocation, yet The Walking Dead opted not to do this. The obvious explanation is that Dead City was always supposed to focus on Maggie and Negan in Manhattan rather than Hilltop as a community, but it would still be a strong one-off episode. Even if it didn't happen in Dead City season 2, I would love to see a future project to explore when exactly Maggie and the rest of the community knew Hilltop was no longer sustainable.
Additionally, seeing the internal decisions on what they should do next alongside the difficulties they faced while on the road would be great. It's still not clear what sort of resources they had for their move or if Alexandria and the Commonwealth helped, and they may even have run into trouble while traveling as such a large group, potentially losing members of the community on their way to the Bricks. Therefore, Hilltop's fall and rebuild still has a lot of potential, and it remains one of The Walking Dead's best under-explored storylines.