Production order is closer to the order Gene Roddenberry originally envisioned.
There are a few other instances of minor things changing between Star Trek's early episodes that make production order work best. As another example, "The Corbomite Maneuver" works better as the first episode to feature Yeoman Janice Rand (Grace Lee Whitney) based on the way Captain Kirk speaks about her. Production order also better illustrates the development of the characters and the ways the series evolved over time. These seemingly small changes make the series flow better. Further, production order is closer to the order Gene Roddenberry originally envisioned.
Watching Star Trek: The Original Series In Release Order Is More Nostalgic (& More Convenient)
Broadcast Order Is How Original Fans Viewed The Series
Watching Star Trek: The Original Series in broadcast order has its fair share of supporters, too, however. Most of the DVD/Blu-ray releases, as well as streaming services, list the episodes in broadcast order, making it more convenient for most viewers. Watching in production order requires viewers to find a list and manually keep track, rather than simply watching the episodes in the order provided. While this is likely a minor inconvenience for die-hard Star Trek fans, the average viewer may just want to dive in without having to think about moving episodes around.
Whether you watched Star Trek: The Original Series in the 1960s or not, there is also a certain nostalgia in watching the series as it originally aired and experiencing it the same way viewers did back then. The inconsistencies regarding Starfleet's uniform changes or lines of dialogue are relatively minor and have little effect on the overall viewing experience. While it's impossible to recreate the exact experience of being a Star Trek fan in the 1960s sitting down to watch that week's newest episode, watching the episodes in release order comes the closest.
Which Is Best For Watching Star Trek: The Original Series: Production Or Release Order?
Production Order Makes The Most Sense When It Comes To Continuity
Ultimately, the adventures of Captain Kirk and Mr. Spock can be watched in any order, as each Star Trek episode can truly be enjoyed on its own. Still, viewing the episodes in production order offers the most authentic experience and represents how Gene Roddenberry intended the show to be watched. Aside from the inconvenience of keeping track of the episodes, production order better illustrates the ways the costumes, characters, and sets evolved throughout the series. During the 1960s, television networks were not concerned with continuity within a series, and the order in which NBC chose to air the episodes was arbitrary.
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds follows Star Trek: The Original Series' episodic format, but with serialized character arcs.
Modern television shows sometimes film episodes out of sequence due to scheduling issues or lengthy post-production processes, but air the episodes in an intentional order to follow a serialized storyline. Because of this, the production order versus release order debate does not apply to later Star Trek series, like Star Trek: The Next Generation. However, Star Trek: The Original Series truly benefits from being viewed in production order, and many Trek viewers consider this to be the definitive order for enjoying the original adventures of the USS Enterprise.